A 7-1 blowout to the Dallas Stars. A 3-2 time beyond regulation loss to the Detroit Red Wings. A 6-2 defeat to the Columbus Blue Jackets.
The Pittsburgh Penguins might have salvaged a shootout win over the lowly San Jose Sharks on Saturday however it hasn’t quieted issues across the crew.
The Penguins’ playoff window is closing shortly. And this final week of play solely emphasised that.
The Penguins’ 7-10-3 begin solely scratches the floor of how daunting their begin to the season has been. The crew has a league-worst minus-25 objective differential, which helps seize simply how dire it has gotten.
It begins with unstable goaltending. Tristan Jarry misplaced the crew’s belief simply three video games into the season, which held him out of NHL motion for nearly a full month after a disastrous efficiency towards the Buffalo Sabres.
One AHL stint later, Jarry is again up with the NHL membership, although he stumbled in his return towards the Blue Jackets on Friday evening. Now, in 4 appearances with the Penguins, he has allowed 4.3 objectives above anticipated primarily based on the shot high quality he has confronted. The actual fact is Jarry isn’t a dependable starter on a crew with playoff hopes, and that was true earlier than his begin to the season.
Sadly, the Penguins don’t have sufficient assist behind him to make up for that. Alex Nedeljkovic solely has three high quality begins in 10 appearances. Joel Blomqvist has had a couple of sturdy outings and has been one of many few vibrant spots at instances, however he isn’t the reply alone. Between the three goalies, the crew has allowed a collective 10.1 objectives above anticipated, second-worst within the league behind solely the Colorado Avalanche.
The goaltenders are a transparent a part of the issue, however this begin doesn’t fall purely on their shoulders. The crew has significantly struggled defensively.
The Penguins are a bottom-five crew in anticipated objectives towards at five-on-five. The crew provides up numerous slot pictures towards, particularly off the cycle, and will get hemmed in its personal zone. The defenders aren’t blocking numerous these pictures or limiting harmful passes. As an alternative, they’re turning the puck over within the impartial zone and sometimes getting caught flatfooted within the defensive finish, which is additional exposing an unstable group of goalies.
It’s a theme up and down the lineup. Kris Letang has struggled in his personal zone and appears overwhelmed when taking part in towards prime competitors. And in contrast to seasons previous, he isn’t making up for it offensively.
Erik Karlsson’s defensive recreation has been underneath a microscope for good cause during the last month. Like Letang, he has been on the ice for a career-high charge of anticipated objectives and instantly contributed to pricey objectives towards. And there doesn’t appear to be a match on his left to maximise his strengths, both. Pairing him with Matt Grzelcyk was abysmal. And Marcus Pettersson, who paired effectively with him final yr, has additionally gotten off to a horrible begin. That pair is at the least creating possibilities of their minutes, however the crew continues to be giving up lots.
Lacking coaching camp with an harm doubtless set Karlsson again, leaving him with extra rust to shake off when the season began. However there haven’t been any indicators of progress.
The Grzelcyk signing seems even worse after simply over a month of play. After his worth trended down in Boston through the years, he has been over-leveraged in Pittsburgh in a top-four function that’s approach over his depths. Final yr’s large defensive signing, Ryan Graves, has made some enhancements after a disappointing first season with the Penguins. However he’s nonetheless making back-breaking errors when this crew wants him to be a dependable shutdown drive.
The gamers look overwhelmed. The coaches don’t appear to have tactical solutions. And this crew doesn’t have the offensive chops to outweigh it. There isn’t sufficient dimension to their assault, with gaps of their rush-based offense. And worst of all, they’re failing to transform on too lots of the possibilities they do generate.
The Penguins are as high-event of a crew as attainable in Sidney Crosby’s minutes. They’re producing a ton of harmful seems however bleeding virtually as many again. When he’s on the bench, the crew has simply 23 five-on-five objectives — they usually’ve given up 41 again. It’s simply one other instance of how basically flawed the crew’s roster building is.
At this level, there isn’t lots to be optimistic about in Pittsburgh. The crew put up possibly their finest efficiency of the season on Nov. 8 towards the red-hot Washington Capitals, solely to stumble by their subsequent 4 video games.
The Stars decimated the Penguins so badly within the first 20 minutes that the subsequent 40 minutes legitimately didn’t matter. A sluggish begin to the Pink Wings proved pricey on Wednesday, and the comeback fell brief in time beyond regulation. The Blue Jackets ended their six-game shedding streak on Friday with a 6-2 win over Pittsburgh. To place some perspective on how unhealthy a loss that was, Columbus responded with a 5-1 loss to Montreal the subsequent evening.
To the Penguins’ credit score, they managed to say each factors towards the Sharks on Saturday evening. However that was solely after blowing a 3-0 result in one of many few groups behind them within the standings. The crew has already misplaced a league-high 4 video games after holding a multi-goal lead and was fortunate to not add to that report towards San Jose.
Perhaps it’s too early to name this all-time low — there are 62 video games left, in any case. But it surely’s been a completely brutal begin.
The Penguins’ present place isn’t precisely distinctive. It’s fairly pure for groups to development down after years of contending — and few have the success Pittsburgh did at its top. The crew hoisted the Stanley Cup in 2009. And after some adjustments round their core, they gained back-to-back in 2016 and 2017.
However whatever the consequence of that playoff window, most groups often hit a wall as a result of contending tends to weigh on a crew’s long-term trajectory. Prospect pipelines and draft swimming pools get depleted for right-now belongings. Commitments to getting older stars can sink a crew, too.
If a crew doesn’t proactively push towards their playoff window closing, they turn out to be destined for a rebuild. That’s how the cycle of competition typically works within the NHL.
GO DEEPER
The NHL Contention Cycle: Where does each team stand now and in the future?
Administration might settle for that destiny and fade into the background. The Stanley Cup period was particular, however the shine is lengthy gone. The GM Ron Hextall period did numerous injury to the Penguins’ long-term outlook. And the beginning of Kyle Dubas’ tenure has had some critical missteps as effectively. However that doubtless isn’t how the franchise needs to finish the Sidney Crosby period, particularly after he signed a two-year extension value $8.7 million a yr that runs by the 2026-27 season. That makes their path ahead all of the extra sophisticated if a rebuild isn’t an actual possibility for an additional two years. If that’s the case, administration has to discover a solution to cease the bleeding and transfer ahead within the brief time period earlier than occupied with a real teardown.
Step one? Accepting the fact and committing to a brand new path.
A crew can’t miss the playoffs in November, however it will possibly tank their possibilities. The Penguins’ odds of reaching the postseason have dropped by 30 percent since the preseason, down to simply seven %. Pittsburgh has cratered whereas others, just like the Capitals, Devils and Senators, have improved. Ready for elimination can be a gross mismanagement of time; the crew has to get a bounce begin on the method as quickly as attainable.
There are simply so many contract hurdles to navigate. Jarry’s deal is an anchor that needs to be cleared for flexibility— more likely to a rebuilding crew much like when the Kings moved Cal Petersen to Philadelphia. It simply will most likely price a sweetener or one other unhealthy contract.
Shopping for him out might appear to be the straightforward reply to opening cap area, however that may very well be the nail within the coffin of the Crosby period as a result of it will depart the Penguins on the hook for $8 million in lifeless area in 2025-26 and $10.2 million in 2026-27 earlier than gaining reduction. A commerce isn’t out of the query, however they’d be promoting low. If he’s moved earlier than the season ends, it will doubtless take up their final retained wage slot (two will open this summer time when Jeff Petry and Reilly Smith hit free company).
As brutal as Karlsson’s begin has been, the most effective answer could also be maximizing the blue line round him. For all his flaws defensively, Karlsson can nonetheless be an elite offensive creator — which this crew can use from the blue line, particularly with holes up entrance. Take his recreation towards the Sabres: defensive lapses led to high quality possibilities, which the goaltending couldn’t cease.However he additionally made a direct influence in time beyond regulation, with a move few defensemen can constantly make to arrange the game-winner.
There’s nonetheless good in Karlsson, however the crew must do numerous work to repair the unhealthy, together with discovering a associate who could make up for his deficiencies (since Pettersson, who he clicked with final yr, doesn’t appear as much as the duty this yr) and a solution to ease his and Letang’s deployment. That ought to be the place Graves is available in, however his recreation has fallen off a cliff since leaving New Jersey. With a modified no-trade and 4 years left on that deal, the Penguins are in a critical bind there.
That might depart Petterson as the one actual commerce chip on protection as a result of Grzelcyk doubtless doesn’t have a lot worth. That will open up about $7 million on protection by the commerce deadline this yr and probably give up-and-coming expertise like Owen Pickering and Jack St. Ivany an opportunity to develop on the NHL degree and assist administration resolve whether or not they can turn out to be regulars subsequent season.
There aren’t a ton of massive commerce belongings up entrance, both. Nonetheless, administration ought to search any avenues to recoup cap area and future belongings. Lars Eller was the first domino to fall, however he shouldn’t be the final. Gamers like Noel Acciari, Anthony Beauvillier and Blake Lizotte (when he’s wholesome) ought to all be on the block. Transferring Rickard Rakell shouldn’t be off the desk both —nobody exterior of Crosby ought to be — however he could also be a tricky promote due to the time period left on his contract.
GO DEEPER
What I’m hearing on the Penguins: More trades are coming
Bringing again draft picks or up-and-coming gamers would assist kickstart the Penguins’ course of. It might bolster a prospect pool that’s far from inspiring. Or it might give the crew extra commerce belongings (and open cap area) to make use of this summer time to speed up a turnaround if the concept is to attempt to attain the playoffs whereas their franchise icon continues to be taking part in. The Penguins don’t essentially have to stockpile belongings to take large swings, just like the Karlsson deal. Administration might use mid-tier belongings to carry again dependable middle-six scorers or versatile depth defensemen. Pittsburgh ought to be taking notes from the Blues’ retool in 2018, and even Washington in 2023 — even when there aren’t as many priceless belongings to maneuver.
Then there’s the teaching to think about. Administration has to resolve whether or not Mike Sullivan can flip issues round. Sullivan isn’t a foul coach — he has one of many longest tenures in a league with a really excessive turnover charge for good cause. He revitalized a crew that wanted a brand new voice again in 2015. However typically, a crew wants to usher in a brand new perspective with totally different concepts, and Pittsburgh could also be approaching that time.
Retooling is a dangerous technique that might in the end burn the crew and set them again additional. Pittsburgh may very well be too far gone at this level to get again to the playoff circle within the subsequent two years. However even when administration doesn’t need to tear the crew down and concentrate on a brand new period of Penguins hockey, committing to a retool on the fly can be higher than the established order and could also be the most effective likelihood of success once more within the Crosby period.
The roster is flawed. The contracts are flawed. Even the teaching employees has turn out to be flawed at this level. So the Penguins should embrace change and carve out a brand new path ahead. At this level, the one approach ahead requires taking a step again this yr and getting ready for the longer term.
Knowledge through Evolving-Hockey, HockeyViz, HockeyStatCards, AllThreeZones and NaturalStatTrick. This story depends on shot-based metrics; here’s a primer on these numbers.
(High picture of Penguins coach Mike Sullivan: Joe Sargent / NHLI through Getty Photographs)
